57 & 59 Gleneida Avenue

Historic Restaurant & Bar Space – Hamlet of Carmel, NY

An iconic opportunity in the heart of Carmel. This former bar and restaurant space, in operation since 1852, is now available for the first time in generations. Steeped in history and character, the property sits prominently in the center of the hamlet of Carmel, surrounded by the Putnam County office buildings & Courthouse, Sheriff’s Office, professional offices, Carmel High School, the post office, and more.

With over 25,000 cars per day passing by, this space offers unbeatable visibility and foot traffic. Currently, there is no bar in the hamlet.

Historic bar/restaurant space dating back to 1852

Prime location in the center of Carmel’s business and civic district

Surrounded by courthouses, county offices, schools, and shops

Over 25,000 cars daily for excellent visibility

Hamlet Mixed-Use Central zoning – flexible for a variety of uses

A unique chance to bring dining, nightlife, or a community hub back to downtown Carmel

This is more than a property—it’s a piece of Carmel’s history, ready for its next chapter.

Permitted uses are governed by the Carmel zoning code and should be confirmed with the municipality. Ask a broker for the district summary.