McGrath RealtyCommercial
Division
Back to all space for lease
For LeaseMixed UseMLS KEY1036767

33 Center Street, Unit 29

Middletown, NY · Orange County
Listed by
KW Hudson Valley United
Shown from OneKey MLS. McGrath Realty does not represent this property. We can arrange to show it to you and represent you in buying it.
Building
3,279 SF
Site
0.06 acres
Stories
2

The offering

29-33 Center St, Middletown, NY 10940

Located directly across from City Hall and next to the public library, this centrally positioned restaurant/bar space offers an excellent opportunity in the heart of Middletown. The property has operated successfully as both a tavern and a soulful restaurant for many years.

The owner has removed the flooring and bar but is in the process to complete general construction work to return the space to a functional restaurant for the right tenant. Any additional customization or specialized build-out will be the tenant’s responsibility. The kitchen is small and that was good enough for a bar, it might not be enough for a restaurant.

This location is ideal for an experienced restaurant or bar operator looking to establish a presence in Middletown—an increasingly vibrant and highly rated community recognized as one of the best places to live in the state. With strong foot traffic and unmatched centrality, this space is positioned for success.

Building & site

Interest conveyedFee simple
Gross building area3,279 SF
Building typeMixed Use
Property typeMixed Use
Stories2
Land area0.06 acres
Land area, SF2,652 SF
WaterPublic
SewerPublic Sewer
HeatNatural Gas
Tax parcel33090031-8-23
Usable area3,279 SF
Electric utilityOrange & Rockland

Aerial imagery

The outline is this property's tax parcel from the county assessment roll, over current aerial imagery. Boundaries are indicative and are not a survey.

Location, access & trade area

Trade area
Measure
Middletown
Orange County
Population
30,289
411,767
Daytime population
27,638
392,941
Population density
6,041 / sq mi
507 / sq mi
Households
9,970
141,127
Median household income
$79,346
$95,298
Mean travel time to work
36 min
35 min
Median home value
$308,600
$426,900
Median gross rent
$1,661
$1,753
Unemployment (May 2026)
4.0%
Not stated
School districts
Middletown, Minisink Valley
ZIP codes
10940

Municipal and county figures from the US Census American Community Survey (2024 5-year) and the Bureau of Labor Statistics. These are jurisdiction totals, not radius rings; ask a broker for a drive-time or radius study on a specific site.

Taxes & assessment

2025 taxes$11,392
Assessed value$39,600
Land assessment$7,600
Full market value$421,300
Owner of record29-33 Center Street Inc
School districtMiddletown
Property class481 · Nbhd tavern

Assessment figures are taken from the municipal roll and should be independently verified. Annual tax bills are available on request.

Comparable offerings

111 Ballyhack Road
Land / Development
111 Ballyhack Road
Patterson · 320.43 acres
$14,900,000
5246 Route 22
Land / Development
5246 Route 22
Amenia · 422.42 acres
$8,900,000
54 Reed Avenue
Land / Development
54 Reed Avenue
North Salem · 164.60 acres
$7,900,000
33 Center Street, Unit 29, Middletown NY | Mixed-Use For Lease