McGrath RealtyCommercial
Division
Back to all property for sale
For SaleHotel/MotelMLS KEY957930

10 Old Route 9

Hyde Park, NY · Dutchess County
Listed by
Atelier WM LLC
Shown from OneKey MLS. McGrath Realty does not represent this property. We can arrange to show it to you and represent you in buying it.
Building
12,437 SF
Site
9.52 acres
Price / SF
$764

The offering

Belvedere Mansion at Pawling Manor

An Enduring Hudson Valley Landmark of Rare Pedigree

Set on 9.52 secluded acres just minutes from Rhinebeck, Belvedere Mansion at Pawling Manor stands as one of the Hudson Valley’s most storied and versatile estates. Anchored by a grand, turn-of-the-century Georgian mansion, the property embodies over three centuries of American history while offering a refined canvas for contemporary luxury hospitality or private estate living.

The six-bedroom main residence has been recently restored and thoughtfully redesigned, achieving a seamless balance between original architectural detail and sophisticated modern comfort. Period millwork, well-proportioned formal rooms, and historic finishes coexist effortlessly with updated systems and amenities, resulting in interiors that feel both elevated and timeless.

Designed for hospitality use, the estate currently encompasses 22 guest rooms (plus three staff rooms) across three buildings, offering immediate operational flexibility. A separate bungalow structure—formerly housing six guest rooms—awaits renovation and presents a compelling opportunity to expand capacity by 4–6 (or more) additional keys, allowing a future owner to further enhance the property’s income potential and/or guest experience.

Though located just four miles south of the Village of Rhinebeck, the estate sits within the Town of Hyde Park, in the hamlet of Staatsburg—an area recognized for its developer-friendly environment and strong support of hospitality projects. This unique positioning combines cultural proximity with favorable zoning rarely found in the region.

Belvedere Mansion is not merely a residence or venue—it is a legacy estate, shaped by generations of visionaries and tastemakers. Its next steward is invited to guide the property into its next incarnation, whether as a world-class boutique hotel, wellness retreat, cultural destination, or extraordinary private compound.

Zoning: Greenbelt, Hotel (nonconforming)

History:

The history of Pawling Manor begins in 1696, when the land formed part of a 6,000-acre royal patent granted to Colonel Henry Pawling. According to records, by 1760, Pawling’s grandson, Major John Pawling, had established a stone and log residence on the site, anchoring what would become one of the Hudson Valley’s enduring estates.

After the original structure was lost to fire in 1899, the current Georgian-style mansion was constructed in 1900 by H.R. Hastings, a prominent figure in New York’s Gilded Age society, reportedly as a wedding gift for his wife, Mary Hastings. The home was designed for entertaining and welcomed a distinguished social circle.

The Beaux Art architecture firm Hoppin and Koen is recorded as having designed the current structure. Its principals, Frances Hoppin and Terence Koen were each mentored by McKim, Mead, and White. Hoppin and Koen are responsible for luminary Hudson Valley structures that include Blithewood and Springwood (FDR's Hyde Park home).

William Schupp, who expanded it into Pawling Manor Farm, and later the Clyde Miller family. In 1959, the property entered a new era as Pawling Health Manor, a pioneering wellness retreat founded by Dr. Robert and Joy Gross. For more than thirty years, it attracted cultural icons including Elizabeth Taylor, James Earl Jones, Cicely Tyson, Miles Davis, Jerry Stiller, and others.

The estate holds a unique boxing legacy, having hosted a regulation ring built by Dr. Gross, a former feather-weight boxing champion, where legendary trainer Cus D’Amato worked with his fighters. In the early 2000s, the property was reborn as Belvedere Mansion, a premier wedding and events destination—most notably serving as the site of Lin-Manuel Miranda’s wedding.

Virtual Data Room Registration: https://docsend.com/view/s/aa6...

AMENITIES:

Three Staff Rooms

Commercial Kitchen

Bar

Tennis Court

Private Natural Pond

Building & site

Interest conveyedFee simple
Gross building area12,437 SF
Building typeHotel/Motel
Property typeHotel/Motel
Land area9.52 acres
Land area, SF414,691 SF
WaterWell
SewerSeptic Tank
HeatForced Air
Tax parcel1332006168-03-410255-0000
Usable area12,437 SF
Number of buildings4
Distance to train6.4 mi

Aerial imagery

The outline is this property's tax parcel from the county assessment roll, over current aerial imagery. Boundaries are indicative and are not a survey.

Location, access & trade area

Trade area
Measure
Hyde Park
Dutchess County
Population
21,240
298,220
Population density
530 / sq mi
375 / sq mi
Households
8,069
116,275
Median household income
$87,094
$99,478
Mean travel time to work
29 min
31 min
Median home value
$331,200
$400,600
Median gross rent
$1,227
$1,582
Unemployment (April 2026)
3.3%
Not stated
School districts
Arlington, Highland, Hyde Park, Kingston, Rhinebeck
ZIP codes
12538, 12569, 12572, 12580, 12601, 12603

Municipal and county figures from the US Census American Community Survey (2024 5-year) and the Bureau of Labor Statistics. These are jurisdiction totals, not radius rings; ask a broker for a drive-time or radius study on a specific site.

Taxes & assessment

2025 taxes$42,187
Assessed value$907,115
Land assessment$110,500
Full market value$2,356,100
Owner of recordNew Belvedere Partners LLC
School districtRhinebeck
Property class414 · Hotel
Estimated annual tax, 2025 roll
County and town$12,065
School, Rhinebeck$26,224
Special districts$1,422
Estimated total$39,711

The estimate is the assessed value at the current county, town, school and village rates. Not a bill: exemptions, and any change to the assessment or the rates, move it.

Assessment figures are taken from the municipal roll and should be independently verified. Annual tax bills are available on request.

Comparable offerings

10 Old Route 9, Hyde Park NY | 12,437 SF Commercial For Sale