McGrath RealtyCommercial
Division
Back to all property for sale
For SaleMixed UseMLS KEY944485

1 Oscawana Lake Road

Putnam Valley, NY · Putnam County
Listed by
Lena Family Realty LLC
Shown from OneKey MLS. McGrath Realty does not represent this property. We can arrange to show it to you and represent you in buying it.
Building
4,625 SF
Site
0.24 acres
Price / SF
$151
NOI
$75,000
Year built
1946
Stories
2

The offering

Prime Mixed-Use Investment Opportunity in the Heart of Putnam Valley

Located at 1 Oscawana Lake Road, Putnam Valley, NY 10579, this highly visible mixed-use property offers a rare opportunity to own a cornerstone investment in one of Putnam Valley’s most walkable and sought-after locations.

The property features a ground-level commercial restaurant with two separate residential units, providing multiple income streams and flexible use potential.

Commercial Restaurant Space: 1,548 ± sq. ft., ideally situated at street level with excellent exposure and foot traffic

Apartment #1: 1,248 ± sq. ft., located above the commercial space, ideal for owner occupancy or rental income

Apartment #2: 581 ± sq. ft., a detached accessory building (“cottage”), offering privacy and additional rental appeal

Set in the heart of Putnam Valley, the property enjoys strong walkability to nearby shops, services, and community amenities. Adding significant future value, a new public municipal parking lot is planned for construction at the former Sheriff’s Office site, greatly enhancing convenience for patrons and tenants.

This property is well-suited for investors, owner-operators, or those seeking a mixed-use asset with long-term upside in a prime location.

Don’t miss the opportunity to own this exceptional investment property in Putnam Valley.

Building & site

Interest conveyedFee simple
Gross building area4,625 SF
Building typeMixed Use
Property typeMixed Use
Year built1946
Stories2
Land area0.24 acres
Land area, SF10,454 SF
WaterShared Well
SewerPublic Sewer
HeatHot Water
Tax parcel37280091.27-1-4
Clear height9 ft
Number of buildings2
Electric utilityNYSEG

Income & tenancy

Gross income (as reported)
$75,000

Lease terms are summarized from the executed lease and should be independently verified against the document, which is available under confidentiality agreement along with the rent roll and operating statements. Income shown is gross as reported by the listing broker, not verified against an operating statement.

Aerial imagery

The outline is this property's tax parcel from the county assessment roll, over current aerial imagery. Boundaries are indicative and are not a survey.

Taxes & assessment

2025 taxes$13,117
Assessed value$463,100
Land assessment$125,000
Full market value$463,100
Owner of record1 Oscawana LLC
School districtPutnam Valley
Property class421 · Nbhd tavern
Floodplain
38% of the parcel lies within the mapped floodplain. Buildable area, insurance and any expansion should be checked against the current FEMA mapping before you rely on it.

Assessment figures are taken from the municipal roll and should be independently verified. Annual tax bills are available on request.

Comparable offerings